Worried About Trump Tariffs? So Are Your Competitors

With President-elect Donald Trump proposing across-the-board tariffs of 10% on all imports and 60% on Chinese imports, U.S. businesses are bracing for significant changes in their sourcing and supply chains. These tariffs aim to boost domestic manufacturing and reduce reliance on China. However, historical evidence and expert analyses suggest such measures often result in unintended consequences, including higher consumer prices, reduced wages, and strained trade relations.

A recent Wall Street Journal article underscores how previous tariff policies slowed economic growth (from 3% in 2018 to 2.6% in 2019), reduced manufacturing output (down 6.2% by the end of 2019), and prompted retaliatory trade actions that hampered U.S. exports. These lessons highlight the importance of proactive, strategic adjustments for businesses navigating today’s volatile trade landscape.

In this article, I’ll address common misconceptions about tariffs—especially in regard to China—and explore how these challenges can become opportunities for businesses to rethink strategies, reorganize operations, and emerge stronger.

Debunking Common Misconceptions

1.“Tariffs are temporary”

The assumption that tariffs are short-lived is misguided. History shows that tariffs, once implemented, often persist for years. The Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 triggered a global trade contraction that deepened the Great Depression, with ripple effects lasting for years. Similarly, tariffs from Trump’s first term remained in place under a Biden administration determined to undo most of Trump’s economic policy, contributing to slower growth and reduced manufacturing output.

For businesses sourcing from China, this means planning for the long term. Relying on short-term fixes, such as quick supplier switches or rushed cost reductions, could lead to inefficiencies and higher risks. A sustainable strategy must account for enduring changes to the trade landscape.

2. “Sourcing Outside China Can Help Businesses Avoid Tariffs”

Shifting production away from China may seem like a logical solution to avoid tariffs, but global geopolitics complicates this assumption. For instance, President-elect Trump has proposed imposing tariffs on goods from Mexico and other trading partners, demonstrating that no country is truly “safe” from trade policy shifts. As I wrote in Brainz Magazine, geopolitics are unpredictable and diplomacy is fickle. It is impossible to predict relations with any substitute country and alternative sourcing regions may face their own challenges in the future.

The most resilient approach involves a balanced strategy: maintaining a strong foundation in China while being strategically agile to reduce risks. Diversification should be done thoughtfully to avoid creating new vulnerabilities.

3. “Domestic manufacturing can fill the gap”

While some tariffs may be intended to encourage domestic production (including “re-shoring”), the inefficiencies of doing so often outweigh the benefits:

• Higher Costs: Producing domestically what could be imported more efficiently drives up expenses for U.S. businesses and consumers.
• Resource Diversion: Shifting labor and capital toward domestic manufacturing reduces productivity in industries where the U.S. excels, such as technology and services.

As the Wall Street Journal article highlights, tariffs can create as many challenges as they aim to solve. Companies must carefully evaluate how nearshoring or reshoring will increase their efficiency and competitiveness. For more insights, see our blog: Buy Direct from China vs US. 

4. “Southeast Asia is a perfect substitute for China”

A popular approach to avoid tariffs is to reduce reliance on China by shifting production to other countries, such as Vietnam, India, or Mexico. While diversification can make sense, such moves come with their own set of challenges:

• Limited Infrastructure: Southeast Asian countries lack the scale and sophistication of China’s manufacturing ecosystem. Vietnam, for example, faces underdeveloped infrastructure and an inability to handle complex manufacturing at scale.
• Limited Industries: China’s supply chain is one of the most sophisticated in the world and supports nearly every product sector, a capability unmatched by emerging markets.
• Less Experienced Workforce: China has been the “factory of the world” for several decades, and for good reason. Its workforce has acquired the knowledge and expertise to excel in nearly every industry: designer handbags, electronics, construction materials, jewelry, etc.
• Higher Logistics Costs: Relocation often results in longer lead times and higher transportation expenses. Many emerging markets are still catching up in terms of logistics networks and infrastructure.
• Potential Quality Issues: Managing consistent quality in new sourcing regions requires significant oversight, due diligence, and on-the-ground support. Without these safeguards, businesses risk higher defect rates and missed deadlines.
• Higher Raw Material Costs: Even in alternative regions, raw materials often come from China, adding costs when transported elsewhere for production.
• Political stability: Fear of political instability prevents the investments needed for production and increases the risk of supply chain disruption. 

Opportunity Amid Crisis

While tariffs undoubtedly increase the cost of imports, every U.S. company is navigating the same challenges. This levels the playing field, creating opportunities for businesses that can adapt and innovate. The key question is: how will you outsmart your competitors?

When your products land in inventory, what matters is how well you can sell them. Will you maintain market share and protect your margins? Some of this depends on sales and marketing, or perhaps securing a waiver (a long shot, especially for smaller companies). However, most of it hinges on effective sourcing and supply chain management.

Offset Tariffs While Staying With the Suppliers You Know

Contrary to popular belief, you don’t need to abandon China to mitigate tariff impacts. You can have your mooncake and eat it, too. Here’s how to maintain your buying edge:

• Negotiate Better Costs: Chinese manufacturers are facing deflationary pressures and are increasingly open to renegotiating terms. Use this opportunity to secure bulk discounts, optimize payment schedules, or reduce overall costs.
• Diversify Without Compromising: Keep your sourcing program in China while exploring opportunities in other regions. This will ensure you are not caught being a “captive buyer.” A buyer with multiple options makes suppliers work hard for their business.
• Build Resilience: Diversification is just one way to increase your supply chain resilience. Developing inventory buffers, establishing contingency plans, and ensuring suppliers have dual production capacities can also mitigate risk. This approach minimizes disruptions and strengthens your supply chain.

Conclusion

While President-elect Trump’s proposed tariffs increase uncertainty, this also creates opportunities for those who are well prepared.  Business “not as usual” compels leaders to rethink their strategies and find ways to innovate. Those who do that best, win. Reacting quickly is also important, strategic decisions made now can mitigate the impact of tariffs later and enable companies to turn obstacles into wins.

Every challenge presents an opportunity for innovation and leadership. With resilience, adaptability, and strategic planning, businesses can not only survive but thrive in this evolving trade environment, while competitors struggle to adapt. 

Offset Tariffs with CPG’s limited time 50% off promotion